The confusion began last month, when Microsoft released Windows 8.1 Update and gave Windows 8.1 commercial and consumer users until 12th May to install it, saying that they otherwise wouldn’t get access to future patches.
Responding to complaints from commercial customers – those who receive fixes via WSUS (Windows Server Update Services), Windows Intune or System Centre Configuration Manager – Microsoft buckled and extended the deadline to August. It kept the original deadline in place for consumers, but then on Monday at the last minute moved it to 10th June.
So Windows 8.1 consumer customers will get access to security fixes through 10th June – including the monthly patches due out today – but Microsoft will not deliver to them fixes for bugs it doesn’t consider security-related, according to a Microsoft spokesman.
By contrast, “consumer customers with Windows 8.1 Update installed will receive all updates, including security,” he wrote via email.
Back in April, Microsoft made it sound like having Windows 8.1 Update would be required, from a technology standpoint, in order for future patches and fixes to work.
“All future security and non-security updates will be built on these latest product updates, so existing Windows 8.1 customers – as well as Windows Server 2012 R2 and Windows Embedded 8.1 Industry customers – will need to be running these latest product updates in order to continue to receive future product improvements and security updates,” Microsoft official Brandon LeBlanc wrote in a blog post back then.
Asked for clarification on this point, another Microsoft spokesman reiterated Monday via email that “all future 8.1 updates – security and non-security – have a dependency on 8.1 Update. This means 8.1 customers will need to install 8.1 Update prior to installing any other updates.”
“Come June 10th, if they haven’t installed 8.1 Update, no other updates will be visible to them in the Windows Update UI because they will be required to install the Update in order to receive any other updates,” he added.
That response would seem to reinforce the idea that Windows 8.1 Update establishes some sort of technology foundation that is necessary for Windows 8.1 users to have in order to install and apply updates.
But what changed from a technology standpoint between April and now that will in fact allow Windows 8.1 PCs to receive and install patches even though they’re not running Windows 8.1 Update?
If Windows 8.1 Update indeed lays down a software code foundation that will be required for fixes and patches to work on Windows 8.1, why will these fixes and patches work on consumer Windows 8.1 PCs through 10th June and on commercial Windows 8.1 PCs through August?
Will there be at some point a technology impediment that makes Windows 8.1 PCs unable to absorb patches and fixes? If not, is the requirement for Windows 8.1 customers to move to Windows 8.1 Update an arbitrary decision by Microsoft? After all, customers who are still on Windows 8 will continue to receive all security and non-security updates through January 2016.
Microsoft have so far been unable to offer clarification on this issue.
In the meantime, installing Windows 8.1 Update isn’t going smoothly for everybody, as evidenced by this long thread on Microsoft’s support discussion forum.
“I agree that this is confusing,” said David Johnson, Analyst, Forrester Research.
Windows 8.1 Update introduces major modifications to the OS, so moving to it is not “a totally seamless process,” and may require reconfiguring certain settings and preferences, he said via email.
There are also the reports of installations gone wrong, and of bugs and of glitches acknowledged by Microsoft.
“This is of special concern for enterprise customers because the update is really more like an upgrade – essentially a rip and replace of the OS – a big deal on the Windows platform,” Johnson said. “Enterprise IT shops need to test compatibility and the upgrade process, and IT service desks need to be ready to help users through the process.”